Published on
Minister McEntee proposes new bill to repeal almost century old Censorship of Publications Act
Minister McEntee proposes new bill to repeal almost century old Censorship of Publications Act
The Minister for Justice Helen McEntee has today obtained government approval to repeal the Censorship of Publications Acts.
The decision follows a review undertaken in the Department to Justice on the continuing need to have censorship provisions for printed publications.
Following the examination, the Censorship of Publications Board and the related Appeal Board are also to be stood down.
“In the almost one hundred years of the censorship of publications legislation, there has been a dramatic shift in social policy and societal values in Ireland.
“The legislation to be repealed was published in 1928 and enacted in 1929. As it stands, the law allows for the censorship and prohibition of books, and of magazines, journals and newspapers that are considered indecent or obscene, or devote disproportionate space to crime.
“We have now come full circle and repeal of the Censorship legislation will reflect the reality that the Censorship Boards are of limited relevance in a modern society. Their mandate is largely unenforceable given the legislation’s dated principles and the focus on physical printed publications.
“Several significant amendments have already been made to the Censorship of Publications Acts, including changes to allow the publication of information on contraception, abortion and divorce.
“Repeal would mark another chapter in moving on from parts of Ireland’s past that no longer have a place in the present.”
The Register currently contains nine books with the earliest dating back to 1942 and the most recent from 2016.
There are currently 264 prohibited periodicals dating from the earliest in 1930 to the most recent in 2003.
“I want to be clear that repeal will not impact on the prosecution of offences for possession or publication of child abuse material or for circulating threatening or abusive material.
“Rather, it is being done on the basis that there are other sufficiently robust statutory provisions in place to deal with these offences.
“There has been a particular focus in my Department on this point, which will continue as Heads of the Bill are drafted.
“There is also a continuing need for effective regulation of on-line content as provided for in the Online Safety and Media Regulation Act 2022.”
With significant groundwork already done, work on the heads of the Bill will proceed with a view to bringing them to Government in 2024
The Department will ensure that specific plans are put in place to archive important records of national historical and cultural value and to carry out a Data Protection Impact Assessment on the storage of the records.
• Minister McEntee today presented a Memorandum for Government to approve the drafting of the Heads of a Bill to repeal the Censorship of Publications Acts.
• The recommendation to proceed with repeal follows a review undertaken in the Department of Justice and is informed by extensive legal advices received over recent years, including most recently earlier this year.
• The legislation to be repealed originally arose directly from a recommendation made by “the Committee on Evil Literature”, which had been appointed by a previous Minister for Justice in 1926. Following from the report of the Committee, the Bill was published in 1928 and enacted in 1929.
• The Censorship of Publications Board became operational in 1930 and over its lifetime has prohibited over 12,000 publications. The ‘Register of Prohibited Publications’ details the prohibition orders in force on books and periodical publications.
• When the legislation is enacted, the Register of Prohibited Publications would be stood down and the censorship provisions ended.
• In practical and operational terms, the Board and Appeal Board have effectively ceased in the last twenty years with significantly reduced volumes of complaints and appeals.
• There have been no members appointed to the Censorship of Publications Board since the last terms of appointment lapsed in November 2021. The Appeal Board has been defunct since 2012 when its membership similarly lapsed having last convened in 2011.
• A process to appoint new members and reconstitute these Boards was put on hold, pending the outcome of the examination by the Department on the continuing need to have censorship provisions for printed publication.